Sally's flawed premises
Submitted by Abelard on March 29 2002 07:00:34
In reply to Re: the eroticisation of love submitted by sally on March 28 2002 00:51:49
|
Sally: "If you are dreaming and wishing for something which God has forbidden how is that OK?" Response: (a) "Can God make a stone so heavy that He/She cannot lift it?" (b) "Can God make a round square?" (c) "If God is all-powerful, can He/She put Him-/Herself out of existence, then come to life with twice the power He/She had originally?" Sally, the problem with your entire train of thought on this board is, as I see it, twofold: (1) You have assumptions that only appeal to a particular kind of fundamentalist Christian worldview. (2) More significantly, your assumptions beg the question (assumes beforehand what needs to be first demonstrated) and are already "pre-loaded" (--"When have you stopped beating your wife?"--) and even tinged with self-contradiction. To get out of these kinds of contradictions one must first presuppose that God supersedes all contradictions. |
Follow ups: